Head-to-Head: Solid vs Stimulus Analysis

solid-js

v1.8.17(about 1 month ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

SolidJS is a declarative JavaScript library for building user interfaces. It focuses on performance and developer experience by using fine-grained reactive updates to efficiently render components. SolidJS leverages a reactive paradigm similar to React, but with a smaller bundle size and faster runtime performance. It also provides a simple API for creating composable and reusable components.

Alternatives:
preact+
vue+
svelte+
react+
inferno+
alpinejs+
mithril+
lit+
hyperapp+
riot+

Tags: javascriptlibraryuser-interfacereactiveperformance

stimulus

v3.2.2(10 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 2Monthly npm downloads

Stimulus is a modest JavaScript framework that enhances your HTML with interactivity and functionality. It focuses on providing a lightweight and unobtrusive way to add behavior to your web pages without the need for complex data binding or virtual DOM manipulation. Stimulus is well-suited for projects where a full-fledged SPA framework like React or Angular may be overkill.

Alternatives:
alpinejs+
htmx+
petite-vue+
marionette+
mithril+
rivets+
intercooler-js+
unpoly+
vue+
svelte+

Tags: javascriptframeworkinteractivitylightweightdeclarative

Fight!

Popularity

React has been the dominant player in the JavaScript ecosystem for a long time and has a massive community and ecosystem built around it. SolidJS, on the other hand, is a relatively new library but has been gaining popularity due to its performance and simplicity. Stimulus is a lightweight JavaScript framework that is not as widely known or popular as React or SolidJS.

Size

SolidJS is known for its small bundle size and efficient rendering algorithm, making it a lightweight option for building web applications. React, while being more feature-rich, has a larger bundle size due to its extensive ecosystem and additional functionalities. Stimulus is also lightweight and focuses on enhancing interactivity in existing HTML, rather than providing a full-fledged framework.

Scalability

React is highly scalable and widely used in large-scale applications. It has a mature ecosystem with tools and libraries that support scalability, such as Redux and React Router. SolidJS, although relatively new, is designed to be scalable and performant, and its reactive nature allows for efficient updates. Stimulus, being a lightweight framework, is more suitable for smaller projects or enhancing interactivity in specific parts of a larger application.

Developer Experience

React has a vast and mature ecosystem with excellent developer tools, extensive documentation, and a large community for support. SolidJS aims to provide a similar developer experience to React, with a familiar API and tooling. Stimulus, while being lightweight, may have a simpler developer experience due to its minimalistic approach and focus on enhancing existing HTML rather than managing complex state and components.

Performance

SolidJS is known for its exceptional performance due to its fine-grained reactivity system and efficient rendering algorithm. React also performs well in most scenarios, but its virtual DOM reconciliation process can introduce some overhead. Stimulus, being a lightweight framework, is designed for enhancing interactivity rather than focusing on raw performance.