Head-to-Head: Semantic UI React vs styled-components Analysis

semantic-ui-react

v2.1.5(6 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 13Monthly npm downloads

Semantic UI React is a popular library that provides React components following the Semantic UI design language. It offers a wide range of customizable and responsive UI components, such as buttons, forms, modals, and menus, making it easy to build visually appealing and user-friendly interfaces. Semantic UI React integrates seamlessly with React applications, allowing developers to create modern and consistent designs with minimal effort.

Alternatives:
reactstrap+
material-ui+
ant-design+
blueprintjs/core+
chakra-ui+
evergreen-ui+
grommet+
react-bootstrap+
prime-react+
rebass+

Tags: reactui-componentsdesign-languagecustomizableresponsive

styled-components

v6.1.11(about 1 month ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 9Monthly npm downloads

Styled-components is a popular CSS-in-JS library for styling React components. It allows you to write actual CSS code to style your components directly within your JavaScript files, providing a more maintainable and scalable styling solution. With styled-components, you can easily create dynamic styles based on props, use nested components, and leverage the full power of CSS features like media queries and keyframes.

Alternatives:
emotion+
linaria+
styled-jsx+
goober+
jss+
aphrodite+
styletron+
glamorous+
stitches+
treat+

Tags: reactcss-in-jsstylingcomponentsdynamic-styles

Fight!

Styling Approach

Semantic-UI-React is a set of React components that implement Semantic UI, a popular CSS framework. It provides pre-designed components with consistent styling out of the box. Styled-Components, on the other hand, is a library for styling React components using CSS-in-JS. It allows for dynamic styling based on props and global theming.

Flexibility

Styled-Components offer more flexibility in terms of styling as it allows you to write actual CSS within your JavaScript code. This can be beneficial for creating highly dynamic and reusable components. Semantic-UI-React, while providing a wide range of pre-built components, may be less flexible when it comes to custom styling.

Performance

In terms of performance, Styled-Components can have a slight overhead due to the CSS-in-JS approach, but it offers optimizations like automatic critical CSS rendering. Semantic-UI-React, being a component library, may have a more predictable performance impact as it comes with pre-optimized components.

Developer Experience

Styled-Components can enhance developer experience by allowing you to create components with encapsulated styles and dynamic theming. It also provides better tooling support for debugging styles. Semantic-UI-React, on the other hand, can speed up development by offering ready-to-use components, but may require more effort for custom styling.

Community and Ecosystem

Both libraries have active communities, but Semantic-UI-React benefits from the larger Semantic UI ecosystem, which includes a wide range of pre-designed themes and components. Styled-Components, being a more specialized library, has a dedicated community focused on CSS-in-JS solutions.