Head-to-Head: Recoil vs Zustand Analysis

recoil

v0.7.7(over 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Recoil is a state management library for React applications developed by Facebook. It provides a simple and efficient way to manage global state in complex React applications. Recoil offers features like atoms for state definition, selectors for derived state, and the ability to subscribe to state changes. It also optimizes re-renders by tracking dependencies at the granularity of individual components.

Alternatives:
zustand+
jotai+
mobx+
redux+
valtio+
effector+
xstate+
akita+
easy-peasy+
pullstate+

Tags: reactstate-managementglobal-stateatomsselectors

zustand

v4.5.2(4 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Zustand is a minimalistic and straightforward state management library for React applications. It offers a simple and intuitive API for managing global state in a React component tree without the need for complex setups or boilerplate code. Zustand leverages React hooks and context under the hood to provide a lightweight yet powerful state management solution.

Alternatives:
redux+
mobx+
recoil+
jotai+
valtio+
effector+
easy-peasy+
pullstate+
react-query+
swr+

Tags: reactstate-managementreact-hookscontext-api

Fight!

State Management Approach

Recoil is a state management library for React that provides several unique features like atoms, selectors, and the ability to manage global state in a more declarative way. Zustand, on the other hand, is a minimalist hook-based state management library that focuses on simplicity and performance.

Developer Experience

Recoil offers a more structured approach to state management with built-in tools for managing complex state interactions. It provides features like selectors for derived state and an easy-to-understand API. Zustand, being minimalist, offers a simpler and more lightweight solution with a focus on ease of use and performance.

Performance

Zustand is known for its excellent performance due to its minimalistic design and optimized re-renders. It leverages React hooks efficiently to manage state updates. Recoil, while performant, may introduce some overhead due to its more feature-rich nature and the additional abstractions it provides for managing state.

Scalability

Recoil is well-suited for larger applications with complex state management needs. Its atom and selector model allows for scalable state management and makes it easier to handle global state in large React applications. Zustand, being lightweight and simple, is more suitable for smaller to medium-sized applications where simplicity and performance are key.

Community and Ecosystem

Recoil is developed and maintained by Facebook and has a growing community around it. It benefits from the resources and expertise of a large organization. Zustand, while not backed by a tech giant, has gained popularity in the React community for its simplicity and performance, and has an active community contributing to its ecosystem.