Head-to-Head: Recoil vs Valtio Analysis

recoil

v0.7.7(12 months ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Recoil is a state management library for React applications. It provides a simple and intuitive way to manage and share state across components, making it easier to build complex and scalable applications. Recoil uses an atom-based model, where atoms represent individual pieces of state that can be read from and written to by components. It also supports selectors, which are derived state values that can be computed based on the atoms.

Alternatives:
zustand+
mobx+
redux+
jotai+
valtio+
effector+
easy-peasy+
xstate+
pullstate+
overmind+

Tags: javascriptreactstate-managementatomsselectors

valtio

v1.13.1(22 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

Valtio is a state management library for React applications. It provides a simple and efficient way to manage and share state across components without the need for complex setup or boilerplate code. Valtio leverages the power of ES6 Proxies to create reactive state objects that automatically update components when the state changes.

Alternatives:
zustand+
recoil+
mobx+
effector+
jotai+
redux+
easy-peasy+
pullstate+
react-query+
swr+

Tags: javascriptreactstate-managementreactiveproxies

Fight!

Popularity

Recoil is a state management library developed by Facebook for React applications and has gained significant popularity and adoption in the React community. Valtio, on the other hand, is a relatively newer library and hasn't gained as much popularity as Recoil.

API Design

Recoil follows a more familiar and declarative API design, similar to React hooks, making it easier for React developers to understand and integrate into their applications. Valtio, on the other hand, provides a minimalistic and functional API, which may require some learning curve for developers who are new to it.

Performance

Both Recoil and Valtio are designed to provide efficient and performant state management. Recoil leverages React's built-in features like React rendering, scheduling, and memoization to optimize the performance of state updates. Valtio also focuses on performance and utilizes a proxy-based state management approach, which offers fast and efficient state updates.

Ecosystem and Community Support

Recoil benefits from being backed by Facebook, which ensures strong ecosystem support, regular updates, and a wider community adoption. It has a growing ecosystem with various community-driven extensions and utilities available. Valtio, being a newer library, has a smaller community and ecosystem, but it's actively maintained and has potential for growth.

Developer Experience

Both libraries provide good developer experiences. Recoil integrates seamlessly with React and provides easy-to-use tools like selectors, atoms, and derived state. It also offers built-in DevTools for debugging and inspecting the Recoil state. Valtio provides a simple and intuitive API to manage and observe state changes and integrates well with JavaScript and TypeScript projects.

Scalability

Recoil is well-suited for large-scale applications due to its optimized rendering and built-in support for selector composition. It offers features like selectors, RecoilRoot, and atom families that make managing complex state structures more scalable. Valtio, although more lightweight, is also scalable and can handle state management efficiently in both small and large applications.