Head-to-Head: React Virtualized Select vs react-window Analysis

react-virtualized-select

v3.1.3(over 6 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/react-virtualized-selectNumber of direct dependencies: 4Monthly npm downloads

React-virtualized-select is a React component that combines the functionality of a virtualized list with a select dropdown. It efficiently renders large datasets by only rendering the visible items, providing smooth scrolling performance. This package is particularly useful for scenarios where you need to display a large number of selectable options without compromising performance.

Alternatives:
react-select+
downshift+
react-window+
react-autocomplete+
react-select-async-paginate+
react-select-fast-filter-options+
react-virtual+
react-infinite+
react-select-virtualized+
react-infinite-scroller+

Tags: reactvirtualizedselectdropdownperformance

react-window

v1.8.10(6 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/react-windowNumber of direct dependencies: 2Monthly npm downloads

React Window is a lightweight and efficient library for rendering large lists and tabular data in React applications. It uses virtualization techniques to render only the items that are currently visible on the screen, resulting in improved performance and reduced memory consumption. React Window is highly customizable and supports both fixed size and variable size items, making it suitable for a wide range of use cases.

Alternatives:
react-virtualized+
react-virtuoso+
react-list+
react-infinite+
react-tiny-virtual-list+
virtuoso+
react-base-table+
react-cool-virtual+
react-grid-layout+
react-spring-bottom-sheet+

Tags: reactvirtualizationperformanceliststabular data

Fight!

Popularity

React-window is more popular and widely used compared to react-virtualized-select. React-window is known for its high performance and efficiency in handling large lists and grids.

Functionality

React-virtualized-select is a library that adds virtualization support to the popular react-select library. It allows for efficient rendering of large dropdown menus or select components. On the other hand, react-window is a standalone library for efficiently rendering large lists or grids. It provides virtualization techniques and scroll optimizations for smooth performance.

Integration

React-virtualized-select integrates with react-select, enabling virtualization for the select component. React-window is more flexible and can be used with various UI frameworks and components, including custom implementations.

Performance

Both packages prioritize performance, but react-window is specialized for rendering large lists and grids efficiently. It uses windowing techniques to only render the items visible in the viewport, resulting in faster initial load times and reduced memory usage. React-virtualized-select improves performance when dealing with large dropdown menus, but its optimizations are specifically tailored for select components.

Community Support

Both packages have active communities and are well-maintained. React-window has a larger community and support base, given its broader use cases. It benefits from ongoing development and bug fixes.

Ease of Use

React-virtualized-select is straightforward to set up if you are already using react-select. React-window requires custom implementation and may have a steeper learning curve. However, react-window provides more granular control and customization options for virtualization purposes.