Head-to-Head: React Static vs UmiJS Analysis

react-static

v7.6.2(about 3 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 71Monthly npm downloads

React-Static is a modern static site generator for React, enabling developers to build fast and SEO-friendly websites. It leverages React's component-based architecture to create dynamic and interactive static sites, offering features like code splitting, server-side rendering, and automatic route-based code splitting. React-Static provides a flexible and efficient way to generate static websites with React, making it ideal for projects that require high performance and scalability.

Alternatives:
next+
gatsby+
nuxt+
eleventy+
sapper+
gridsome+
hexo+
hugo+
jekyll+
vuepress+

Tags: reactstatic-site-generatorSEO-friendlyserver-side-renderingcode-splitting

umi

v4.3.26(about 11 hours ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 12Monthly npm downloads

Umi is a comprehensive front-end development framework that streamlines the creation of React applications. It offers a rich plugin ecosystem, enabling developers to extend and customize their projects with ease. Umi provides built-in support for routing, state management, and server-side rendering, making it suitable for building complex and scalable applications.

Alternatives:
next+
nuxt+
gatsby+
remix+
docusaurus+
sapper+
redwoodjs+
blitz+
elderjs+
gridsome+

Tags: javascriptframeworkreactfront-endroutingserver-side-rendering

Fight!

Popularity

Both React Static and Umi are popular choices in the React ecosystem. React Static has gained popularity for its simplicity and ease of use, while Umi is known for its powerful features and extensive plugin ecosystem.

Architecture

React Static is a static site generator that focuses on generating static HTML and assets at build time. It is suitable for building static websites and blogs. Umi, on the other hand, is a full-featured framework that provides a development server, routing, and build tools. It is designed for building scalable and complex web applications.

Developer Experience

React Static offers a simple and intuitive developer experience. It has a minimal configuration setup and provides a fast development workflow. Umi, on the other hand, has a steeper learning curve due to its extensive feature set and configuration options. It provides more flexibility but may require more time to set up and configure.

Routing

React Static uses a file-based routing system where each file represents a route. It is straightforward and easy to understand. Umi, on the other hand, provides a powerful routing system with support for dynamic routes, nested routes, and route-based code splitting. It offers more advanced routing capabilities for complex applications.

Plugins and Extensibility

Umi has a rich plugin ecosystem that allows developers to extend and customize the framework easily. It provides a wide range of plugins for features like internationalization, state management, and UI libraries integration. React Static, on the other hand, has a more limited plugin ecosystem and may require more custom development for specific needs.

Community and Support

Both React Static and Umi have active communities and good support. React Static has a smaller community but is known for its helpful and responsive maintainers. Umi has a larger community and benefits from being part of the Ant Design ecosystem, which provides additional resources and support.