Head-to-Head: React Helmet vs react-helmet-async Analysis

react-helmet

v6.1.0(about 4 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.The package doesn't have any types definitionsNumber of direct dependencies: 4Monthly npm downloads

React Helmet is a popular library for managing the document head of React applications. It allows developers to dynamically set meta tags, title, links, scripts, and other elements in the document head based on the current state of the application. This is particularly useful for improving SEO by ensuring proper metadata for search engines and social media platforms.

Alternatives:
react-helmet-async+
react-meta-tags+
next-seo+
react-head+
react-document-meta+
react-snap+
gatsby-plugin-react-helmet+
vue-meta+
next-head+
react-seo-component+

Tags: reactdocument-headmeta-tagsSEOdynamic

react-helmet-async

v2.0.5(about 1 month ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

React Helmet Async is a library for managing document head tags in React applications asynchronously. It allows developers to dynamically update the title, meta tags, links, and other elements in the document head based on the current state of the application. React Helmet Async provides a simple and declarative API for managing SEO-related metadata, social media tags, and other document head content.

Alternatives:
react-helmet+
react-meta-tags+
next-seo+
react-document-meta+
react-head+
react-snap+
gatsby-plugin-react-helmet+
vue-meta+
next-head+
react-side-effect+

Tags: reactseodocument-headmetadataasynchronous

Fight!

Functionality

Both React Helmet and React Helmet Async are packages that allow you to manage the document head in a React application. They provide similar functionality, allowing you to dynamically update the title, meta tags, and other elements of the document head based on the current state of your application.

Synchronous vs Asynchronous

The main difference between the two packages is the way they handle rendering and updating of the document head. React Helmet is synchronous, which means it updates the document head immediately during the render phase. React Helmet Async, as the name suggests, is asynchronous and updates the document head after the component has rendered. This can be useful in scenarios where you need to dynamically update the document head based on asynchronous data or user interactions.

Performance

In terms of performance, React Helmet Async has an advantage over React Helmet. By deferring the updates to the document head, React Helmet Async can prevent unnecessary re-renders and improve the overall performance of your application. However, the performance difference might not be significant for smaller applications.

Developer Experience

Both packages have a similar API and are easy to use. React Helmet follows a more traditional synchronous approach, which might be more familiar to developers. React Helmet Async introduces a slightly different API to handle asynchronous updates. Depending on your preference and the specific requirements of your project, you can choose the package that aligns better with your development style.

Community and Maintenance

Both React Helmet and React Helmet Async have active communities and are well-maintained. They receive regular updates and bug fixes. However, React Helmet has been around for longer and has a larger user base, which means it might have more community support and resources available.