Head-to-Head: react-async vs Recoil Analysis

react-async

v10.0.1(about 4 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

React-async is a library for managing asynchronous data fetching in React applications. It simplifies the process of handling asynchronous operations by providing hooks and components that make it easy to fetch data and handle loading, error, and success states. React-async allows you to declaratively define data dependencies and manage the loading state without the need for complex state management logic.

Alternatives:
react-query+
swr+
axios-hooks+
use-http+
react-fetch-hook+
react-request+
use-axios-client+
react-async-hook+
use-promise+
react-use-fetch-factory+

Tags: reactasyncdata-fetchinghookscomponents

recoil

v0.7.7(about 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Recoil is a state management library for React applications developed by Facebook. It provides a simple and efficient way to manage global state in complex React applications, offering features like atoms, selectors, and asynchronous data fetching. Recoil leverages React's built-in features like hooks and context API to provide a flexible and scalable state management solution.

Alternatives:
mobx+
zustand+
redux+
flux+
jotai+
valtio+
effector+
easy-peasy+
pullstate+
overmind+

Tags: reactstate-managementatomsselectorsasynchronous-data-fetching

Fight!

Popularity

React-async and Recoil are both popular npm packages within the React ecosystem. React-async is widely used for handling asynchronous operations in React components, while Recoil is gaining popularity as a state management library for React applications.

Functionality

React-async is specifically designed to handle asynchronous operations in React components, providing utilities like `useAsync` and `useFetch` hooks. It simplifies handling loading, error, and success states for asynchronous operations. Recoil, on the other hand, is a state management library that provides a more general-purpose solution for managing state in React applications, including global state, derived state, and atom-based state management.

Integration with React

Both React-async and Recoil are designed to seamlessly integrate with React. They provide React-specific APIs and hooks to enhance the development experience. React-async focuses on handling asynchronous operations within components, while Recoil focuses on managing state in a React-friendly way.

Developer Experience

React-async provides a straightforward and intuitive API for handling asynchronous operations in React components. It offers built-in support for error handling, loading states, and caching. Recoil, on the other hand, introduces a new approach to state management in React, which may require a learning curve for developers who are not familiar with its concepts. However, Recoil provides powerful features like selectors and atom families for managing complex state interactions.

Community and Support

Both React-async and Recoil have active communities and are actively maintained. React-async has a smaller community compared to Recoil, which is backed by Facebook. Recoil benefits from the support and contributions of the React team and has a growing ecosystem of extensions and integrations.