Head-to-Head: Playwright vs Puppeteer Analysis

playwright

v1.44.0(12 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Playwright is a Node.js library for automating browsers, enabling developers to write reliable end-to-end tests for web applications. It provides a single API to automate Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit browsers, allowing for cross-browser testing. Playwright offers advanced features like automatic waiting, network interception, and parallel execution, making it a powerful tool for testing complex web applications.

Alternatives:
puppeteer+
selenium-webdriver+
cypress+
testcafe+
webdriverio+
nightwatch+
taiko+
protractor+
karma+
intern+

Tags: node.jsbrowser automationend-to-end testingcross-browser testingweb applications

puppeteer

v22.9.0(3 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 4Monthly npm downloads

Puppeteer is a Node.js library that provides a high-level API to control headless Chrome or Chromium over the DevTools Protocol. It allows you to automate tasks like web scraping, testing, and generating screenshots of web pages. Puppeteer offers a rich set of features for interacting with web pages, such as navigating, clicking elements, filling forms, and capturing network requests.

Alternatives:
playwright+
selenium-webdriver+
webdriverio+
nightwatch+
cypress+
taiko+
testcafe+
puppeteer-core+
protractor+
casperjs+

Tags: node.jsbrowser automationweb scrapingtestingheadless chrome

Fight!

Popularity

Puppeteer was introduced earlier and gained significant popularity, being widely adopted by developers. Playwright, however, has gained momentum in recent years and is rapidly growing in popularity due to its expanded functionality and cross-browser support.

Browser Support

Puppeteer has excellent support for Google Chrome and can be used with other Chromium-based browsers. Playwright, on the other hand, provides cross-browser support and allows automation on Chrome, Firefox, and WebKit (Safari), making it a more versatile option when testing or automating across multiple browsers.

API Design

Puppeteer and Playwright have similar API designs, as both strive to provide a high-level, easy-to-use API for browser automation and testing. However, Playwright's API has been designed with better consistency across different browser engines, making it easier to switch between supported browsers.

Functionality

Both packages offer a wide range of functionality for browser automation, including page navigation, DOM manipulation, form submission, screenshot capture, and more. However, Playwright introduces some additional features such as automatic parallelization of tests, recording and replaying networks requests, and the ability to emulate mobile devices.

Community and Support

Puppeteer has a larger and more mature community with extensive resources, documentation, and a vibrant ecosystem. However, Playwright is backed by Microsoft, which provides strong support and resources, and its growing community is rapidly catching up in terms of support and contributions. It's worth noting that both packages have active maintainers and receive regular updates.

Scalability and Performance

In terms of scalability, Playwright offers better scalability due to its ability to run tests in parallel across multiple browser instances. As for performance, Playwright and Puppeteer are both performant, but Playwright's multi-browser support and optimized execution make it slightly more efficient.