Head-to-Head: node-fetch vs Request (deprecated) Analysis

node-fetch

v3.3.2(9 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

Node-fetch is a lightweight and flexible library that provides a window.fetch equivalent for Node.js environments. It allows you to make HTTP requests easily and efficiently, supporting features like streaming, promises, and async/await syntax. Node-fetch simplifies the process of fetching resources from the web and handling responses in a Node.js application.

Alternatives:
axios+
got+
superagent+
ky+
bent+
isomorphic-fetch+
make-fetch-happen+
undici+
cross-fetch+
fetch-h2+

Tags: node.jshttpfetchrequestspromises

request

v2.88.2(about 4 years ago)

This package is deprecated: request has been deprecated, see https://github.com/request/request/issues/3142Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/requestNumber of direct dependencies: 20Monthly npm downloads

Request is a simplified HTTP client for making requests in Node.js. It provides an easy-to-use interface for sending HTTP requests, handling cookies, following redirects, and managing authentication. Request supports both HTTP and HTTPS protocols and offers features like streaming, piping, and multipart/form-data uploads. It is widely used for making API calls, fetching data from servers, and interacting with web services.

Alternatives:
axios+
node-fetch+
got+
superagent+
ky+
bent+
isomorphic-fetch+
make-fetch-happen+
phin+
needle+

Tags: node.jshttpclientrequestapi

Fight!

Popularity

Both Node-fetch and Request are popular npm packages for making HTTP requests in Node.js. However, Request has been around for longer and has a larger user base, making it more widely recognized and commonly used.

Size

Node-fetch is a lightweight and minimalistic package, which only includes the functionality needed for making HTTP requests. Request, on the other hand, is a more comprehensive package that includes additional features like request pooling, cookies, and multipart form data. As a result, Request has a larger code base and may be heavier in size.

Flexibility

Node-fetch provides a simple and straightforward API that aligns well with the modern Fetch API, making it easy to use and integrate with other libraries. Request, on the other hand, offers a more extensive and flexible API with support for various request options like headers, authentication, and custom transformations. This flexibility can be advantageous for complex scenarios but may be overwhelming for simple use cases.

Support and Maintenance

Both Node-fetch and Request are actively maintained and have a supportive community. However, Node-fetch is more modern and aligns with the current web standards, which improves its long-term supportability. Request, while still widely used, has entered maintenance mode and is not actively adding new features.

Performance

Node-fetch is known for its excellent performance and is often recommended for its speed and efficiency. It leverages the native Fetch API in Node.js and provides a lightweight implementation. Request, being a more comprehensive package, may have slightly more overhead due to additional features and dependencies. However, the performance difference between the two is generally negligible in most use cases.