Head-to-Head: Nightmare vs Nightwatch Analysis

nightmare

v3.0.2(about 5 years ago)

This package is deprecated. Consider finding alternatives.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/nightmareNumber of direct dependencies: 14Monthly npm downloads

Nightmare is a high-level browser automation library for Node.js, built on top of Electron. It allows developers to automate interactions with web pages, such as clicking elements, filling forms, and scraping data. Nightmare provides a simple API for creating and running browser automation scripts, making it ideal for tasks like web scraping, testing, and UI automation.

Alternatives:
puppeteer+
playwright+
cypress+
webdriverio+
testcafe+
selenium-webdriver+
taiko+
casperjs+
zombie+
phantom+

Tags: node.jsbrowser automationweb scrapingtestingUI automation

nightwatch

v3.6.3(28 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 34Monthly npm downloads

Nightwatch is a comprehensive end-to-end testing framework for web applications that uses the W3C WebDriver API to perform automated browser testing. It provides a simple and easy-to-use syntax for writing test scripts in JavaScript, allowing developers to create robust and maintainable test suites. Nightwatch supports various browsers and offers built-in commands for common testing tasks like assertions, element interactions, and page navigation.

Alternatives:
webdriverio+
cypress+
playwright+
puppeteer+
testcafe+
selenium-webdriver+
protractor+
taiko+
codeceptjs+
jest-playwright+

Tags: testingend-to-endautomationbrowserJavaScript

Fight!

Purpose

Nightmare is a high-level browser automation library that uses Electron to control Chromium. It is suitable for end-to-end testing, browser automation, and scraping tasks. Nightwatch, on the other hand, is a testing framework that uses Selenium WebDriver to automate browser interactions. It is specifically designed for end-to-end testing of web applications.

Ease of Use

Nightmare is known for its simple and intuitive API, making it easy to write browser automation scripts. It provides a more straightforward and user-friendly experience for those who are new to browser automation. Nightwatch, while powerful, has a steeper learning curve due to its configuration and setup requirements.

Flexibility

Nightmare is more flexible in terms of the tasks it can perform, such as scraping websites or automating complex browser interactions. Nightwatch, being a testing framework, is more focused on end-to-end testing of web applications and provides features like assertions, test runners, and reporting tools.

Community Support

Nightwatch has a larger community and ecosystem compared to Nightmare. This means that finding resources, plugins, and support for Nightwatch might be easier. Nightmare, while still actively maintained, has a smaller community and fewer resources available.

Performance

Nightwatch, being built on top of Selenium WebDriver, can be slower in execution compared to Nightmare, which directly controls Chromium via Electron. For tasks that require speed and efficiency, Nightmare might be a better choice. However, Nightwatch's integration with Selenium allows for cross-browser testing, which is essential for web applications.