Head-to-Head: mobx-state-tree vs react-async Analysis

mobx-state-tree

v6.0.0(18 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

MobX-State-Tree is a state management library for React applications that combines the simplicity and ease of MobX with a structured, transactional approach to managing application state. It allows you to define complex data structures with built-in support for snapshots, patches, and actions, making it easy to create scalable and maintainable applications.

Alternatives:
redux+
vuex+
easy-peasy+
valtio+
zustand+
recoil+
effector+
jotai+
xstate+
akita+

Tags: reactstate-managementmobxreactive-programmingdata-structures

react-async

v10.0.1(about 4 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

React-async is a library for managing asynchronous data fetching in React applications. It simplifies the process of handling asynchronous operations by providing hooks and components that make it easy to fetch data and handle loading, error, and success states. React-async allows you to declaratively define data dependencies and manage the loading state without the need for complex state management logic.

Alternatives:
react-query+
swr+
axios-hooks+
use-http+
react-fetch-hook+
react-request+
use-axios-client+
react-async-hook+
use-promise+
react-use-fetch-factory+

Tags: reactasyncdata-fetchinghookscomponents

Fight!

Popularity

Both MobX-State-Tree and React-Async are popular npm packages in their respective domains. MobX-State-Tree is widely used for state management in React applications, while React-Async is a popular choice for handling asynchronous operations in React.

Functionality

MobX-State-Tree is a powerful state management library that provides a predictable state container with built-in support for mutable and immutable data structures, actions, and reactions. It offers a declarative way to define and manipulate complex application state. React-Async, on the other hand, focuses on handling asynchronous operations in React components, providing utilities for managing loading, error, and success states of asynchronous tasks.

Integration with React

Both libraries integrate well with React. MobX-State-Tree provides a seamless integration with React components, allowing for efficient re-rendering of components based on state changes. React-Async is specifically designed for React and provides hooks and components that can be easily used within React components to handle asynchronous operations.

Developer Experience

MobX-State-Tree offers a simple and intuitive API for managing state in React applications. It provides clear patterns for defining and updating state, making it easy to reason about and maintain. React-Async also provides a developer-friendly API with hooks and components that simplify handling asynchronous operations in React components.

Scalability

MobX-State-Tree is well-suited for managing complex application state and scales well as the application grows. It provides features like snapshots, patches, and middleware that enable efficient state management in large-scale applications. React-Async is focused on handling asynchronous operations and is scalable in terms of managing multiple asynchronous tasks within React components.

Community and Support

Both libraries have active communities and are well-maintained. MobX-State-Tree has been around for a longer time and has a larger community, which means there are more resources and community support available. React-Async also has a growing community and provides good documentation and support.