Head-to-Head: MobX vs react-async Analysis

mobx

v6.12.3(18 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

MobX is a simple, scalable state management library for JavaScript applications. It enables you to create reactive data models that automatically update when the underlying data changes. MobX follows a more direct and transparent approach compared to other state management solutions like Redux, reducing boilerplate code and making it easier to work with complex data structures.

Alternatives:
redux+
vuex+
zustand+
recoil+
easy-peasy+
valtio+
effector+
jotai+
xstate+
akita+

Tags: javascriptstate-managementreactive-programmingdata-modelsscalable

react-async

v10.0.1(about 4 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

React-async is a library for managing asynchronous data fetching in React applications. It simplifies the process of handling asynchronous operations by providing hooks and components that make it easy to fetch data and handle loading, error, and success states. React-async allows you to declaratively define data dependencies and manage the loading state without the need for complex state management logic.

Alternatives:
react-query+
swr+
axios-hooks+
use-http+
react-fetch-hook+
react-request+
use-axios-client+
react-async-hook+
use-promise+
react-use-fetch-factory+

Tags: reactasyncdata-fetchinghookscomponents

Fight!

Popularity

Both MobX and React-Async are popular npm packages in their respective domains. MobX has gained a significant amount of popularity in the React ecosystem due to its simple and powerful state management capabilities. React-Async, on the other hand, is a popular library used for handling asynchronous operations in React applications.

Functionality

MobX is primarily focused on state management and provides a simple and reactive way to manage application state. It supports observables, observable arrays, computed values, and actions to facilitate state mutations. React-Async, on the other hand, is designed specifically for handling asynchronous operations in React components. It provides hooks and components to handle data fetching, loading states, and error handling.

Integration with React

Both packages are designed to work seamlessly with React. MobX integrates well with React components and provides easy-to-use decorators and hooks to access and update reactive state. React-Async is built to work as a companion library to React and provides hooks and components that can be used within React components to handle async operations.

Developer Experience

MobX provides a simple and intuitive API that can be quickly understood and adopted. It offers powerful features like automatic dependency tracking and reaction-based updates, making it easy to manage complex state logic. React-Async also offers a straightforward API for handling async operations in React, with built-in support for data fetching and error handling. Both libraries have good documentation and active communities to support developers.

Performance

In terms of performance, MobX is known for its reactivity model, where components update only when their dependencies change. This can lead to efficient rendering and optimized re-renders. React-Async focuses more on handling async operations efficiently and provides features like automatic cancellation of unfinished requests. The performance of both packages heavily depends on how they are used and optimized in the specific scenario.

Scalability

Both MobX and React-Async are scalable and can be used in small to large-scale applications. MobX provides a scalable state management solution with its reactivity model, allowing for easy organization and management of application state. React-Async helps in managing asynchronous operations and can handle complex async flows efficiently.