Head-to-Head: Material Design Lite vs Semantic UI React Analysis

material-design-lite

v1.3.0(over 7 years ago)

This package is deprecated. Consider finding alternatives.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/material-design-liteNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

Material Design Lite (MDL) is a front-end framework developed by Google that allows developers to easily incorporate Google's Material Design principles into their web projects. It provides a set of CSS, HTML, and JavaScript components that help create modern and responsive user interfaces with a clean and consistent design. MDL offers components like buttons, cards, menus, and sliders, following the Material Design guidelines.

Alternatives:
material-components-web+
materialize-css+
rmwc+
react-md+
vue-material+
material-ui+
vuetify+
mdbootstrap+
quasar+
angular-material+

Tags: front-endframeworkmaterial-designresponsivecomponents

semantic-ui-react

v2.1.5(4 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 13Monthly npm downloads

Semantic UI React is a popular library that provides React components following the Semantic UI design language. It offers a wide range of customizable and responsive UI components, such as buttons, forms, modals, and menus, making it easy to build visually appealing and user-friendly interfaces. Semantic UI React integrates seamlessly with React applications, allowing developers to create consistent and modern-looking designs with minimal effort.

Alternatives:
reactstrap+
material-ui+
ant-design+
chakra-ui+
blueprintjs/core+
react-bootstrap+
evergreen-ui+
grommet+
prime-react+
rebass+

Tags: reactui-componentsdesign-languageresponsivecustomizable

Fight!

Popularity

Both Material Design Lite (MDL) and Semantic UI React are popular choices in the React ecosystem. However, Semantic UI React has gained more popularity and has a larger community following.

Design and Styling

Material Design Lite (MDL) follows the Material Design guidelines and provides a clean and modern design out of the box. It offers a set of pre-styled components and a grid system. Semantic UI React, on the other hand, provides a more customizable and flexible design system with a wide range of components and themes.

Integration with React

Semantic UI React is specifically built for React and provides a set of React components that are easy to use and integrate into React applications. MDL, on the other hand, is a CSS framework that requires additional JavaScript to make it work with React. While MDL can be used with React, Semantic UI React offers a more seamless integration.

Component Ecosystem

Semantic UI React has a larger and more comprehensive component ecosystem compared to MDL. It provides a wide range of reusable and customizable components, including form elements, modals, dropdowns, and more. MDL, on the other hand, offers a smaller set of components and focuses more on providing a consistent design language.

Documentation and Community Support

Both packages have well-documented APIs and active communities. However, Semantic UI React has more extensive documentation, including examples and guides, making it easier for developers to get started and find solutions to common problems. It also has a larger community, which means more community-driven resources and support.

Performance

In terms of performance, Semantic UI React is known to have a larger bundle size compared to MDL. However, with proper optimization techniques like code splitting and tree shaking, the impact on performance can be mitigated. It's important to consider the specific performance requirements of your project when choosing between the two.