Head-to-Head: Material Components for the web vs styled-components Analysis
material-components-web
v14.0.0(over 1 year ago)
The Material Components for the web (MDC Web) is an open-source project that provides a development and integration platform for building high-quality user experiences. It allows developers to implement Google's Material Design guidelines using HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. MDC Web includes many UI components like buttons, cards, text fields, menus and many more that are designed to make web development faster and more consistent. These components are customizable and are built with accessibility in mind.
Styled-components is a popular CSS-in-JS library for building user interfaces in modern web applications. It allows developers to define styles for their React components using JavaScript and provides simple, intuitive APIs for managing them.
Alternatives: emotion, jss, css-modules
Tags: reactcss-in-jsmodularperformancescalability
Fight!
Popularity
Material-Components-Web and Styled-Components are both popular choices in the JavaScript community. However, Material-Components-Web is more focused on implementing the Material Design guidelines and is widely used in projects following that design language, while Styled-Components is more flexible and can be used in various design systems and styles.
Styling Approach
Material-Components-Web provides pre-built Material Design components that come with their own styling, allowing you to quickly and easily implement consistent Material Design UI. Styled-Components, on the other hand, is a CSS-in-JS library that allows you to write component-based styles with JavaScript, giving you more control over your styles and enabling dynamic styling based on props and state.
Integration with Frameworks
Material-Components-Web is designed to work seamlessly with the Material Design framework, making it a great choice if you are building a project following Material Design guidelines. Styled-Components, on the other hand, can be used with any JavaScript framework or library, giving you more flexibility in choosing your front-end stack.
Developer Experience
Material-Components-Web has its own set of components and API specific to implementing Material Design, which makes it easy to use if you are familiar with Material Design concepts. Styled-Components provides a simpler and more intuitive styling approach using template literals, and allows you to write styles directly within your components, improving developer productivity.
Performance
Material-Components-Web provides optimized components and styles specifically designed for Material Design, which can result in better performance compared to a more generic styling solution like Styled-Components. However, the performance difference might be negligible in most cases and will highly depend on the specific usage and implementation.
