Head-to-Head: Material Components for the web vs styled-components Analysis

material-components-web

v14.0.0(almost 2 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 49Monthly npm downloads

Material Components for the web is a set of UI components built with the Material Design guidelines in mind. It provides a collection of reusable and customizable components that help developers create modern and visually appealing user interfaces. Material Components for the web follows the Material Design principles of motion, interaction, and visual design, resulting in a consistent and intuitive user experience.

Alternatives:
@mui/material+
antd+
chakra-ui+
react-bootstrap+
blueprintjs/core+
semantic-ui-react+
primevue+
quasar+
vuetify+
svelte-material-ui+

Tags: javascriptui-componentsmaterial-designresponsiveaccessibility

styled-components

v6.1.8(about 2 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 9Monthly npm downloads

Styled Components is a popular CSS-in-JS library for styling React components. It allows you to write CSS code directly in your JavaScript files using tagged template literals. This approach offers several benefits, including scoped styles, dynamic styling based on props, and easy composition of styles.

Alternatives:
emotion+
linaria+
styled-jsx+
jss+
goober+
aphrodite+
styletron+
glamorous+
stitches+
radium+

Tags: javascriptcss-in-jsstylingreactcomponents

Fight!

Popularity

Both Material Components Web and Styled Components are popular npm packages in the JavaScript community. Material Components Web is widely used for implementing Material Design in web applications, especially in frameworks like React and Angular. Styled Components, on the other hand, is popular for its CSS-in-JS approach and is commonly used in React projects.

Functionality

Material Components Web provides a comprehensive set of pre-built UI components following the Material Design guidelines. It offers a wide range of components like buttons, cards, dialogs, and more. Styled Components, on the other hand, is a library for styling React components using CSS-in-JS. It allows you to write CSS directly in your JavaScript code, providing a more component-centric approach to styling.

Integration

Material Components Web is designed to work seamlessly with frameworks like React and Angular. It provides dedicated libraries and components for these frameworks, making it easy to integrate Material Design into your application. Styled Components, on the other hand, is framework-agnostic and can be used with any JavaScript framework or library, including React, Vue, and Angular.

Developer Experience

Material Components Web provides a consistent and familiar UI experience by following the Material Design guidelines. It has good documentation and community support. Styled Components, on the other hand, offers a convenient and intuitive way to style components using JavaScript. It provides features like theming, dynamic styling, and CSS prop support, which can enhance the developer experience.

Customization

Material Components Web provides a set of predefined styles and components that follow the Material Design guidelines. While it offers some customization options, it may be more challenging to achieve highly customized designs. Styled Components, on the other hand, allows for extensive customization as you can write your own CSS directly in JavaScript. This gives you more flexibility and control over the styling of your components.

Performance

Material Components Web is optimized for performance and follows best practices for rendering and interaction. It leverages the power of CSS and provides optimized JavaScript code. Styled Components also performs well, but it adds an additional layer of abstraction by generating unique class names for styled components, which may have a slight impact on performance.