Head-to-Head: Jotai vs Redux Analysis

jotai

v2.7.0(6 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

Jotai is a state management library for React applications. It provides a simple and scalable solution for managing state in your components. Jotai follows the principles of atomic state and uses atoms as the fundamental building blocks. Atoms are units of state that can be read and updated independently, allowing for fine-grained control over your application's state.

Alternatives:
recoil+
zustand+
redux+
mobx+
valtio+
effector+
react-query+
swr+
react-redux+
easy-peasy+

Tags: javascriptreactstate-managementatomscontext-api

redux

v5.0.1(2 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

Redux is a predictable state container for JavaScript applications. It provides a centralized store to manage the state of an application and enables predictable state updates through a concept called reducers. Redux is commonly used with React, but it can be used with any JavaScript framework or library.

Alternatives:
mobx+
zustand+
recoil+
effector+
easy-peasy+
valtio+
jotai+
redux-toolkit+
rematch+
fluxible+

Tags: javascriptstate-managementpredictableunidirectional-data-flowmiddleware

Fight!

Architecture

Jotai is a relatively new state management library that follows the atom-based approach. It provides a lightweight and intuitive way to manage state in React applications. Redux, on the other hand, is a more established and mature state management library that follows a centralized, action-based architecture.

Size and Performance

Jotai is a smaller library compared to Redux. It has a minimal bundle size and is optimized for performance. Redux, being more feature-rich and supporting various middleware and plugins, may result in a larger bundle size. However, Redux has also undergone performance optimizations over time and is used in large-scale applications without significant performance issues.

Developer Experience

Both Jotai and Redux have good developer experience, but there are some differences. Jotai leverages React's context API and hooks, making it easier to use and understand for React developers. It has a simplified API and a smaller learning curve. Redux, on the other hand, has a more extensive ecosystem, including many third-party middleware and devtools, which can provide a more comprehensive development experience. However, this can also lead to more boilerplate code and complexity compared to Jotai.

Compatibility

Redux is compatible with any JavaScript framework, not just React. It can be used with React, Angular, Vue, or even vanilla JavaScript. Jotai, in contrast, is built specifically for React and tightly integrated with React's context API and hooks. If you are using React as your primary framework, Jotai provides a more seamless integration experience.

Community and Ecosystem

Redux has a large and mature community with extensive documentation, tutorials, and a wide range of third-party middleware and devtools. There are also many existing Redux-based libraries and packages available. Jotai, being a newer library, has a smaller community and ecosystem. It may have less documentation and fewer third-party packages available. However, the Jotai community is growing, and it has good community support.

Use Cases

Redux is well-suited for complex state management scenarios, especially in large-scale applications with intricate data flows. It provides a robust solution for managing a global state and synchronizing actions across components. Jotai, on the other hand, shines in simpler state management scenarios or small to medium-sized applications where a lightweight, context-based state management solution is preferred. It is a great choice for projects that value simplicity and minimalism.