Head-to-Head: ember-apollo-client vs urql Analysis
ember-apollo-client
v4.1.1(about 1 year ago)
Ember Apollo Client is a powerful addon for integrating Apollo Client with Ember applications. It provides seamless integration of GraphQL queries, mutations, and subscriptions into Ember components, making it easier to fetch and manage data from a GraphQL API. Ember Apollo Client simplifies the process of setting up a GraphQL client in Ember applications and offers features like caching, optimistic UI updates, and error handling.
Alternatives:
ember-graphql-adapter-+
ember-apollo-+
ember-orbit-+
ember-data-+
ember-cli-mirage-+
ember-fetch-+
ember-graphql-client-+
ember-graphql-+
ember-network-+
ember-apollo-server-+
Tags: embergraphqlclientaddonintegration
urql
v4.1.0(3 months ago)
Urql is a lightweight and versatile GraphQL client for React applications. It offers a simple and intuitive API for fetching and managing GraphQL data, with built-in caching and automatic updates. Urql focuses on performance and efficiency, providing features like automatic batching and deduplication of requests to minimize network traffic. It also supports server-side rendering and integrates seamlessly with popular state management libraries like Redux and MobX.
Alternatives:
react-query-+
swr-+
apollo-client-+
react-relay-+
react-fetching-library-+
axios-hooks-+
use-http-+
react-apollo-hooks-+
graphql-hooks-+
fetch-suspense-+
Tags: graphqlclientreactperformancecaching
Fight!
Popularity
Both Ember Apollo Client and Urql have their own communities and user bases. However, Urql has gained significant popularity in recent years due to its lightweight and flexible nature, while Ember Apollo Client is more specific to the Ember.js framework and has a smaller user community.
Integration with Frameworks
Ember Apollo Client is specifically designed for seamless integration with the Ember.js framework. It provides Ember-specific features and conventions, making it easier to work with GraphQL in Ember applications. On the other hand, Urql is a framework-agnostic library that can be used with any JavaScript framework, including Ember.js.
GraphQL Features
Both libraries provide support for GraphQL. Ember Apollo Client is built on top of Apollo Client and inherits its extensive set of features, including caching, optimistic UI, and subscriptions. Urql, on the other hand, has a more lightweight approach and focuses on offering a minimalistic API with basic GraphQL functionality.
Learning Curve
Ember Apollo Client requires familiarity with the Ember.js framework. If you are already experienced with Ember.js, integrating and working with Ember Apollo Client will be relatively straightforward. Urql has a simpler and more lightweight API, which might make it easier to learn and use, especially if you are not already familiar with Ember.js.
Community Support
Both packages have active communities and provide support through forums, documentation, and GitHub repositories. However, since Urql has gained wider popularity and is framework-agnostic, it might have a larger and more diverse community for seeking help, finding examples, and getting support.
Performance
In terms of performance, Urql has a focus on being lightweight and optimized for fast rendering. It adopts a fine-grained approach to control caching and provides better fine-tuning capabilities. Ember Apollo Client leverages the caching and data management features from Apollo Client, which might introduce additional overhead compared to the more lightweight approach of Urql.
