Head-to-Head: ember-apollo-client vs Relay Analysis

ember-apollo-client

v4.1.1(about 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.The package doesn't have any types definitionsNumber of direct dependencies: 7Monthly npm downloads

Ember Apollo Client is a powerful addon for integrating Apollo Client with Ember applications. It provides seamless integration of GraphQL queries, mutations, and subscriptions into Ember components, making it easier to fetch and manage data from a GraphQL API. Ember Apollo Client simplifies the process of setting up a GraphQL client in Ember applications and offers features like caching, optimistic UI updates, and error handling.

Alternatives:
ember-graphql-adapter+
ember-apollo+
ember-orbit+
ember-data+
ember-cli-mirage+
ember-fetch+
ember-graphql-client+
ember-graphql+
ember-network+
ember-apollo-server+

Tags: embergraphqlclientaddonintegration

relay-runtime

v17.0.0(2 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/relay-runtimeNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

Relay-runtime is a JavaScript framework for building data-driven React applications. It provides a declarative and efficient way to fetch and manage data for your components, optimizing performance by batching and caching network requests. Relay-runtime is specifically designed to work with GraphQL, allowing you to define data requirements at the component level and automatically handle data fetching and updates.

Alternatives:
apollo-client+
urql+
graphql-request+
apollo-link-state+
react-query+
swr+
react-relay+
react-apollo+
apollo-cache-inmemory+
react-fetching-library+

Tags: javascriptreactgraphqldata-fetchingperformance

Fight!

Purpose

Ember Apollo Client is specifically designed to integrate Apollo Client with Ember applications, providing a seamless GraphQL integration. Relay Runtime, on the other hand, is part of the Relay framework and is used for managing GraphQL queries and their results in React applications.

Integration

Ember Apollo Client offers a more straightforward integration with Ember applications, as it is tailored for this framework. Relay Runtime, on the other hand, is tightly integrated with React and the Relay framework, providing advanced features for managing GraphQL data in React applications.

Community Support

Relay Runtime is backed by Facebook and has a strong community support within the React ecosystem. Ember Apollo Client, while supported by the Ember community, may have a smaller user base compared to Relay Runtime.

Learning Curve

Ember Apollo Client may have a lower learning curve for developers already familiar with Ember, as it provides a more Ember-specific approach to working with GraphQL. Relay Runtime, on the other hand, has a steeper learning curve due to its tight integration with the Relay framework and specific patterns it enforces.

Performance

Relay Runtime is known for its efficient data fetching and caching strategies, optimized for React applications. Ember Apollo Client's performance may vary depending on the complexity of the Ember application and the GraphQL queries being made.