Head-to-Head: Downshift vs React Autocomplete Analysis

downshift

v9.0.6(28 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 5Monthly npm downloads

Downshift is a flexible and accessible library for building autocomplete, combobox, and select dropdown components in React. It provides a simple yet powerful API for managing the state and behavior of these complex UI components, allowing for easy customization and integration with different design systems. Downshift focuses on performance optimization and keyboard accessibility, making it suitable for building inclusive and user-friendly interfaces.

Alternatives:
react-select+
react-autocomplete+
autocomplete.js+
react-autosuggest+
react-dropdown-select+
react-power-select+
react-windowed-select+
react-virtualized-select+
react-fast-compare+
fuse.js+

Tags: reactautocompletecomboboxdropdownaccessibility

react-autocomplete

v1.8.1(over 6 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/react-autocompleteNumber of direct dependencies: 2Monthly npm downloads

React-autocomplete is a React component that provides an easy-to-use and customizable autocomplete functionality for input fields. It allows users to quickly search and select from a list of options as they type, enhancing the user experience in forms and search functionalities. The component offers features like keyboard navigation, customizable styling, and support for asynchronous data fetching.

Alternatives:
downshift+
react-select+
autocomplete.js+
react-autosuggest+
@material-ui/lab+
@headlessui/react+
@reach/combobox+
react-power-select+
react-dropdown-select+
@blueprintjs/select+

Tags: reactautocompleteinputcomponentuser-experience

Fight!

Functionality

Both 'downshift' and 'react-autocomplete' are popular npm packages for building autocomplete functionality in React applications. They provide similar core functionalities such as handling user input, filtering options, and rendering suggestions. However, 'downshift' offers more advanced features like item selection, keyboard navigation, and flexible rendering options, making it suitable for more complex autocomplete scenarios.

API Design

'downshift' follows a render prop pattern, where the autocomplete logic is decoupled from the visual representation. It provides a flexible and customizable API that allows developers to have full control over the rendering and behavior of the autocomplete component. On the other hand, 'react-autocomplete' uses a simpler API with default renderers, making it easier to get started for basic use cases but with less flexibility for customization.

Popularity and Community Support

'downshift' has gained significant popularity and has a strong community behind it, which means good community support, regular updates, and a thriving ecosystem. 'react-autocomplete' also has a decent user base but may have fewer resources and community contributions compared to 'downshift'. It's essential to consider the size and engagement of the community when choosing between the two libraries.

Bundle Size

'downshift' is designed to be lightweight and has a smaller bundle size compared to 'react-autocomplete', making it a better choice for projects where bundle size is a concern.

TypeScript Support

Both libraries have good TypeScript support and provide type definitions out of the box, allowing you to take advantage of static typing and better development experience when working with TypeScript.