Head-to-Head: BackstopJS vs Pixelmatch Analysis

backstopjs

v6.2.2(4 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/backstopjsNumber of direct dependencies: 18Monthly npm downloads

BackstopJS is an open-source tool that automates visual regression testing for web applications. It provides an easy way to test the visual appearance and behavior of web page components by taking screenshots of a website and comparing them to previous versions. BackstopJS can be easily integrated into your existing workflow by running it in the command line or using the API. It also supports multiple scenarios and devices for cross-browser testing.

Alternatives: Percy, Cypress, Selenium

Tags: visual-regression-testingweb-developmenttestingautomated-testingtool

pixelmatch

v5.3.0(over 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/pixelmatchNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Pixelmatch is a lightweight and fast JavaScript library for image comparison and pixel-level image diffing. It is commonly used in automated visual regression testing to detect visual differences between images. Pixelmatch provides an easy-to-use API for comparing images pixel by pixel and generating diff images that highlight the differences.

Alternatives: resemble.js, blink-diff, pixelmatchjs

Tags: javascriptimage-comparisonvisual-regression-testingpixel-level-diffing

Fight!

Functionality

BackstopJS is a visual regression testing tool that compares screenshots of different versions of a website or application to detect visual differences. It provides powerful features for automated visual testing and regression testing workflows. Pixelmatch, on the other hand, is a lightweight pixel-level image comparison library. It is more focused on providing low-level image comparison functionality and does not have the same level of automation and testing workflow capabilities as BackstopJS.

Integration

BackstopJS is specifically designed for integration with test frameworks like Mocha or Jasmine and can easily be incorporated into continuous integration (CI) pipelines. It provides a command-line interface (CLI) and configuration options to control the testing process. Pixelmatch, on the other hand, is a standalone library that can be integrated into custom testing frameworks or scripts. It requires manual setup and coding to perform image comparison tasks.

Usage

BackstopJS is suitable for projects that require comprehensive visual regression testing, especially for larger projects or projects with complex UI components. It provides a higher level of abstraction and automation, making it easier to set up and manage visual regression tests. Pixelmatch, on the other hand, is more lightweight and can be used for simpler image comparison tasks where a full testing framework like BackstopJS is not necessary.

Performance

In terms of performance, Pixelmatch is generally faster due to its focused and optimized codebase. It is designed for efficient pixel-level image comparison, making it ideal for tasks that require high performance and low resource usage. BackstopJS, on the other hand, provides additional features and abstraction layers, which can result in slightly slower performance compared to Pixelmatch.

Community and Maintenance

Both BackstopJS and Pixelmatch have active communities and are actively maintained. BackstopJS has a larger user base and more community support due to its broader range of functionality and use cases. Pixelmatch, although less widely known, is still actively maintained and receives updates from its contributors.