Head-to-Head: BackstopJS vs jest-image-snapshot Analysis

backstopjs

v6.3.23(4 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/backstopjsNumber of direct dependencies: 18Monthly npm downloads

BackstopJS is a visual regression testing tool for web applications. It allows developers to compare visual differences between different versions of a website or web application, helping to catch unintended changes in the UI caused by code updates. BackstopJS captures screenshots of web pages and compares them pixel by pixel, highlighting any discrepancies.

Alternatives:
puppeteer+
playwright+
cypress+
webdriverio+
testcafe+
nightwatch+
taiko+
selenium-webdriver+
protractor+
jest-puppeteer+

Tags: visual-regression-testingweb-applicationsUI-testingautomated-testing

jest-image-snapshot

v6.4.0(6 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are provided via a separate npm package: @types/jest-image-snapshotNumber of direct dependencies: 8Monthly npm downloads

jest-image-snapshot is a Jest plugin that enables snapshot testing for images in your JavaScript projects. It allows you to easily compare and validate visual changes in your application by capturing and comparing image snapshots. This is particularly useful for UI testing, ensuring that visual components render correctly and consistently.

Alternatives:
cypress-image-snapshot+
puppeteer-to-istanbul+
mocha-snapshots+
karma-snapshot+
ava-snapshot+
snapshot-diff+
chai-image-snapshot+
storyshots-puppeteer+
visual-regression-jest+
reg-suit+

Tags: jestsnapshot-testingimage-comparisonvisual-regression-testingUI-testing

Fight!

Functionality

Both BackstopJS and jest-image-snapshot are npm packages used for visual regression testing in JavaScript projects. BackstopJS is a powerful tool that allows you to capture screenshots of web pages and compare them against a set of reference images to detect visual changes. It provides a wide range of configuration options and supports complex scenarios. Jest-image-snapshot, on the other hand, is a plugin for Jest that enables visual regression testing by comparing image snapshots of React components. It integrates seamlessly with Jest and provides a simple and intuitive API for capturing and comparing component snapshots.

Integration

BackstopJS can be used with any testing framework and can be integrated into your existing test suite. It supports various browsers and provides a command-line interface for easy execution. Jest-image-snapshot, on the other hand, is specifically designed to work with Jest and is tightly integrated with the Jest testing framework. If you are already using Jest for your testing, jest-image-snapshot provides a seamless integration experience.

Community and Support

Both BackstopJS and jest-image-snapshot have active communities and are well-maintained. BackstopJS has been around for longer and has a larger user base, which means there is more community support and resources available. Jest-image-snapshot, being a plugin for Jest, benefits from the popularity and support of the Jest ecosystem.

Ease of Use

BackstopJS requires some initial setup and configuration to define scenarios and reference images. It provides a powerful configuration file that allows you to customize various aspects of the testing process. Jest-image-snapshot, on the other hand, is easier to set up and use, especially if you are already familiar with Jest. It leverages the snapshot testing feature of Jest, which makes it straightforward to capture and compare component snapshots.

Flexibility

BackstopJS offers more flexibility in terms of testing complex web pages and scenarios. It allows you to define multiple scenarios, interact with the page, and perform actions before capturing screenshots. It also provides advanced features like automated scrolling and handling dynamic content. Jest-image-snapshot, on the other hand, is more focused on testing React components and provides a simpler and more streamlined approach for capturing and comparing component snapshots.

Performance

In terms of performance, BackstopJS can be slower compared to jest-image-snapshot, especially when testing large web pages with complex scenarios. Jest-image-snapshot, being a plugin for Jest, benefits from the performance optimizations of Jest and is generally faster when testing React components.