Head-to-Head: Primer CSS vs Astroturf Analysis

@primer/css

v21.3.1(about 1 month ago)

This package is actively maintained.The package doesn't have any types definitionsNumber of direct dependencies: 2Monthly npm downloads

@primer/css is a collection of CSS utility classes and components developed by GitHub's design system Primer. It provides a set of customizable and reusable styles for building modern and responsive web interfaces. The package includes utility classes for spacing, typography, colors, layout, and more, allowing developers to quickly style their applications without writing custom CSS from scratch.

Alternatives:
tailwindcss+
bootstrap+
bulma+
foundation-sites+
tachyons+
spectre.css+
semantic-ui-css+
uikit+
purecss+
milligram+

Tags: cssutility-classescomponentsresponsive-designgithub

astroturf

v1.2.0(about 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 26Monthly npm downloads

Astroturf is a zero-runtime CSS-in-JS solution for styling React components. It allows developers to write CSS directly in JavaScript using familiar CSS syntax, which is then transformed into efficient, scoped CSS at build time. Astroturf provides a seamless integration with React components, enabling the use of dynamic styles, theming, and CSS variables.

Alternatives:
styled-components+
emotion+
linaria+
goober+
stitches+
styletron+
jss+
aphrodite+
glamorous+
radium+

Tags: javascriptreactcss-in-jsstylingbuild-time

Fight!

Popularity

Both @primer/css and astroturf are popular npm packages in their respective domains. @primer/css is a utility CSS framework developed by GitHub for building web interfaces, while astroturf is a CSS-in-JS library for styling React components. Both packages have gained popularity and have a growing community.

Use Case

While @primer/css is primarily focused on providing a CSS framework for GitHub's design system and may be more suitable for GitHub-related projects, astroturf is focused on enhancing the CSS-in-JS experience and is a better fit for projects where styling React components using CSS-in-JS is a requirement.

Functionality

The functionality of @primer/css differs from astroturf. @primer/css provides a set of utility CSS classes and components that follow GitHub's design system. It is highly customizable and provides commonly used styling options. On the other hand, astroturf is specifically designed to solve the problem of styling React components using a CSS-in-JS approach. It offers powerful features like scoped CSS, dynamic styles, and static extraction.

Developer Experience

Both packages offer good developer experiences, but they have different approaches. @primer/css provides a ready-to-use CSS framework with predefined styling options and classes, making it easy to style components quickly. Astroturf, as a CSS-in-JS library, allows developers to write and manage CSS within JavaScript or TypeScript files, offering more flexibility and improved type safety when working with stylesheets.

Community Support

Both @primer/css and astroturf have active communities and are actively maintained. However, @primer/css is officially developed by GitHub and benefits from their resources and community support. Astroturf also has a dedicated community contributing to its development and offering support to its users.