Head-to-Head: Popper vs Tippy.js Analysis

@popperjs/core

v2.11.8(about 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.The package doesn't have any types definitionsNumber of direct dependencies: 0Monthly npm downloads

@popperjs/core is a lightweight and powerful JavaScript library for positioning poppers (pop-up elements) near their reference elements. It offers a flexible and customizable solution for creating tooltips, dropdowns, and other UI components that need dynamic positioning. Popper.js uses the Popper positioning engine to calculate the optimal position of poppers based on various factors like size, placement, and boundaries.

Alternatives:
tippy.js+
floating-ui+
tooltip.js+
react-tooltip+
react-popper+
popper.js+
react-tippy+
popmotion+
react-floater+
svelte-popperjs+

Tags: javascriptlibrarypositioningpoppertooltip

tippy.js

v6.3.7(over 2 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Tippy.js is a lightweight, highly customizable tooltip library for modern web development. It offers a simple yet powerful API for creating tooltips with various styles, animations, and interactive behaviors. Tippy.js is known for its flexibility, allowing developers to easily customize the appearance and behavior of tooltips to suit their specific needs.

Alternatives:
popper.js+
tooltip.js+
balloon-css+
react-tooltip+
hint.css+
popper-core+
floating-ui+
microtip+
shepherd.js+
popmotion-pose+

Tags: javascripttooltiplibrarycustomizableinteractive

Fight!

Functionality

@popperjs/core is a library that provides the core positioning logic for popovers, tooltips, and other UI components. It focuses on the positioning and collision detection aspects of UI elements. On the other hand, Tippy.js is a library that builds on top of Popper.js and provides a more feature-rich and customizable tooltip and popover solution with animations, themes, and interactive elements.

Popularity

Both @popperjs/core and Tippy.js are popular libraries in the UI components ecosystem. @popperjs/core is widely used as the core positioning engine for various UI libraries and frameworks. Tippy.js, being a higher-level library, is popular for its feature-rich tooltips and popovers with a focus on customization and interactivity.

Flexibility

@popperjs/core is more focused on the core positioning logic and provides a solid foundation for building custom UI components. It offers flexibility in terms of positioning strategies and collision detection. Tippy.js, on the other hand, is more opinionated and provides a higher-level API with pre-built tooltip and popover styles and animations, offering less flexibility but more convenience for common use cases.

Performance

In terms of performance, @popperjs/core is optimized for positioning calculations and collision detection, making it lightweight and efficient. Tippy.js, with its additional features and animations, may introduce some overhead in terms of performance compared to @popperjs/core. However, the performance impact might be negligible for most use cases.

Developer Experience

@popperjs/core provides a low-level API for positioning elements, which might require more manual configuration and customization but offers more control over the positioning logic. Tippy.js, on the other hand, provides a higher-level API with easy-to-use methods for creating tooltips and popovers with built-in styles and animations, enhancing the developer experience for quick implementations.