Head-to-Head: NGXS vs Recoil Analysis

@ngxs/store

v18.0.0(4 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

@ngxs/store is a state management library for Angular applications that leverages the power of RxJS observables and Angular's change detection. It provides a simple and efficient way to manage the state of your application by using a Redux-inspired pattern with actions, states, and selectors. @ngxs/store offers features like immutability, time-travel debugging, and plugin ecosystem support.

Alternatives:
@ngrx/store+
akita+
mobx-angular+
ngxs+
ngx-observable-store+
angular-redux/store+
@datorama/akita-ngdevtools+
@ngneat/elf+
@ngrx/component-store+
@rx-angular/state+

Tags: angularstate-managementrxjsreduxobservables

recoil

v0.7.7(over 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

Recoil is a state management library for React applications developed by Facebook. It provides a simple and efficient way to manage global state in complex React applications. Recoil offers features like atoms for state definition, selectors for derived state, and the ability to subscribe to state changes. It also optimizes re-renders by tracking dependencies at the granularity of individual components.

Alternatives:
zustand+
jotai+
mobx+
redux+
valtio+
effector+
xstate+
akita+
easy-peasy+
pullstate+

Tags: reactstate-managementglobal-stateatomsselectors

Fight!

State Management Approach

Both @ngxs/store and Recoil are state management libraries, but they have different approaches. @ngxs/store is a state management pattern inspired by Redux but with a more Angular-friendly syntax, while Recoil is a state management library specifically designed for React applications, focusing on providing a simple and efficient way to manage global state.

Developer Experience

@ngxs/store is well-integrated with Angular and provides decorators and utilities that make state management in Angular applications more straightforward. On the other hand, Recoil is tailored for React and leverages React hooks to manage state, offering a more React-centric approach to state management.

Performance

Recoil is known for its efficient and performant state management, utilizing features like atom families and selectors to optimize re-renders. @ngxs/store also offers good performance, but Recoil's design specifically targets minimizing unnecessary re-renders and optimizing state updates.

Community and Ecosystem

@ngxs/store has a strong community within the Angular ecosystem, with good support and a variety of plugins and extensions available. Recoil, being a newer library, is gaining popularity within the React community, and its ecosystem is growing with additional tools and utilities being developed.

Scalability

Both @ngxs/store and Recoil are scalable for medium to large applications. @ngxs/store provides features like actions, selectors, and plugins to manage complex state logic effectively. Recoil's atom families and selectors also support scalable state management, making it suitable for applications of varying sizes.