Head-to-Head: NGXS vs Overmind Analysis

@ngxs/store

v3.8.2(6 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

@ngxs/store is a state management library for Angular applications, inspired by Redux. It provides a simple and efficient way to manage the state of your application using a single store and immutable state changes. With @ngxs/store, you can easily define actions, selectors, and reducers to handle state changes in a predictable and testable manner.

Alternatives:
@ngrx/store+
akita+
mobx-angular+
ngxs+
ngx-observable-store+
angular-redux/store+
@datorama/akita+
@ngx-pwa/local-storage+
@rx-angular/state+
ngrx-store-freeze+

Tags: angularstate-managementreduximmutable-statepredictable-state-changes

overmind

v28.0.3(11 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 4Monthly npm downloads

Overmind is a state management library for React applications that focuses on developer experience and ease of use. It provides a simple and intuitive API for managing application state, actions, and effects. Overmind emphasizes declarative state management, making it easy to reason about and maintain complex state logic.

Alternatives:
mobx+
redux+
zustand+
recoil+
effector+
easy-peasy+
valtio+
jotai+
pullstate+
unistore+

Tags: javascriptstate-managementreactdeclarativedeveloper-experience

Fight!

Popularity

Both @ngxs/store and Overmind are popular state management solutions in the JavaScript ecosystem. @ngxs/store is specifically designed for Angular applications and has a strong presence within the Angular community. Overmind, on the other hand, is a more general-purpose state management library that can be used with any JavaScript framework.

Scalability

Both @ngxs/store and Overmind are scalable and can handle complex state management requirements. However, @ngxs/store provides more built-in features and conventions for managing large-scale applications, making it a better choice for enterprise-level projects. Overmind, on the other hand, is more lightweight and flexible, which can be advantageous for smaller projects or projects with specific customization needs.

Developer Experience

Both libraries offer a good developer experience, but they have different approaches. @ngxs/store follows a more traditional Redux-like pattern with actions, reducers, and selectors, which can be familiar to developers already experienced with Redux. Overmind, on the other hand, takes a more functional and declarative approach, providing a simpler and more intuitive API. It also offers powerful developer tools for debugging and inspecting the state.

Integration

While @ngxs/store is specifically designed for Angular applications and integrates seamlessly with Angular's change detection and dependency injection system, Overmind is framework-agnostic and can be used with any JavaScript framework or library. This makes Overmind a more flexible choice if you are working with multiple frameworks or if you want to keep your options open for future framework changes.

Community and Ecosystem

Both @ngxs/store and Overmind have active communities and provide good documentation. However, @ngxs/store benefits from being part of the Angular ecosystem, which means it has a larger community, more resources, and better integration with other Angular libraries and tools. Overmind, on the other hand, has a smaller but growing community and offers a more focused and opinionated approach to state management.