Head-to-Head: Material-UI vs react-helmet-async Analysis

@material-ui/core

v4.12.4(almost 2 years ago)

This package is deprecated: Material UI v4 doesn't receive active development since September 2021. See the guide https://mui.com/material-ui/migration/migration-v4/ to upgrade to v5.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 12Monthly npm downloads

@material-ui/core is a popular and comprehensive UI component library for React applications. It provides a wide range of reusable and customizable components, such as buttons, inputs, cards, and navigation elements, following the Material Design guidelines. These components are designed to be easy to use and integrate seamlessly into your React projects.

Alternatives:
@mui/material+
antd+
chakra-ui+
react-bootstrap+
blueprintjs/core+
semantic-ui-react+
evergreen-ui+
rebass+
grommet+
primeReact+

Tags: reactui-componentsmaterial-designthemingresponsive-design

react-helmet-async

v2.0.4(2 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

React Helmet Async is a lightweight and efficient library for managing the head tags of your React application. It allows you to dynamically update the title, meta tags, and other head elements based on the current state of your application. With React Helmet Async, you can easily set the title of your page, add meta tags for SEO purposes, set the favicon, and much more.

Alternatives:
react-helmet+
react-meta-tags+
react-document-meta+
react-document-title+
next-seo+
next-head+
gatsby-plugin-react-helmet+
vue-meta+
svelte-head+
react-snap+

Tags: javascriptreacthead-tagsseoserver-side-rendering

Fight!

Popularity

@material-ui/core is a highly popular and widely used library for building UI components in React. It has a large and active community, extensive documentation, and a wide range of pre-built components. react-helmet-async, on the other hand, is a niche library specifically designed for managing document head tags asynchronously in React applications. While it may not have the same level of popularity as @material-ui/core, it is well-regarded within its specific use case.

Functionality

@material-ui/core provides a comprehensive set of UI components and utilities for building responsive and accessible user interfaces. It covers a wide range of use cases and offers customization options. react-helmet-async, on the other hand, focuses solely on managing document head tags, allowing you to dynamically update the title, meta tags, and other head elements based on the current state of your React application.

Developer Experience

@material-ui/core has a well-documented API, a large number of examples, and a vibrant community. It follows Material Design principles and provides a consistent and intuitive development experience. react-helmet-async also has good documentation and is easy to integrate into a React project. It provides a simple and declarative API for managing document head tags asynchronously.

Integration

@material-ui/core is designed to seamlessly integrate with React applications. It provides a set of components that are specifically built for React and can be easily used within a React component hierarchy. react-helmet-async is also designed for React and can be integrated into a React application without much hassle. It provides hooks and components that can be used to manage document head tags within a React component.

Performance

@material-ui/core is optimized for performance and provides features like lazy loading and code splitting to ensure efficient rendering of components. react-helmet-async is lightweight and designed to have minimal impact on performance. It uses asynchronous loading techniques to ensure that managing document head tags does not block the rendering of the rest of the application.