Head-to-Head: Material-UI vs React Desktop Analysis

@material-ui/core

v4.12.4(about 2 years ago)

This package is deprecated: Material UI v4 doesn't receive active development since September 2021. See the guide https://mui.com/material-ui/migration/migration-v4/ to upgrade to v5.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 12Monthly npm downloads

@material-ui/core is a popular React component library that provides a set of customizable and accessible UI components for building modern web applications. It follows Google's Material Design guidelines, offering a wide range of components like buttons, cards, dialogs, and more, all styled with a consistent design language.

Alternatives:
@mui/material+
antd+
chakra-ui+
blueprintjs/core+
react-bootstrap+
semantic-ui-react+
rebass+
grommet+
evergreen-ui+
primevue+

Tags: reactui-componentsmaterial-designaccessiblecustomizable

react-desktop

v0.3.9(over 5 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.The package doesn't have any types definitionsNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

React-Desktop is a library that enables developers to create cross-platform desktop applications using React. It provides components and APIs for building native-like desktop interfaces with React, allowing developers to leverage their existing React skills for desktop app development. React-Desktop offers features like window management, system tray integration, and native menus, making it suitable for building desktop applications that look and feel like native apps.

Alternatives:
proton-native+
react-spectrum+
reactxp+
react-primitives+
react-figma+
react-juce+
react-nodegui+
react-sketchapp+
react-tv+
react-ape+

Tags: reactdesktopcross-platformnativecomponents

Fight!

Popularity

@material-ui/core is one of the most popular UI component libraries for React and has a large and active community. It is widely used in many different projects, from small applications to large-scale enterprise applications. On the other hand, react-desktop is relatively less popular and has a smaller community.

Design and Styling

@material-ui/core follows Material Design principles and provides a wide range of pre-designed and customizable components. It offers a modern, clean, and aesthetic design out of the box. In contrast, react-desktop aims to provide a native desktop look and feel, mimicking the style of macOS and Windows. It is suitable for building desktop applications with a traditional desktop interface.

Component Range

@material-ui/core offers a comprehensive set of UI components including buttons, inputs, grids, navigation, and more. It covers a wide range of use cases, making it suitable for building various types of applications. react-desktop, on the other hand, focuses more specifically on desktop-related components such as windows, menus, notifications, and file pickers. It provides a specialized set of components that are specifically tailored for desktop application development.

Ease of Use

@material-ui/core provides a well-documented API and has a straightforward integration with React. It follows React's component-based architecture and leverages React's virtual DOM for efficient rendering. It has good documentation and a large number of community resources and examples available. react-desktop also offers a simple API, but it might require more customization and manual styling compared to @material-ui/core. It has a smaller community, which might result in fewer resources and examples.

Customizability

@material-ui/core provides ample customization options for its components. It offers theming support and allows you to easily customize the look and feel of the components to match your application's branding. react-desktop, on the other hand, focuses more on providing a consistent native desktop experience and may offer less flexibility in terms of customization.

Integration

@material-ui/core integrates seamlessly with React and has excellent compatibility with other existing React libraries and tools. It is well-maintained and frequently updated to ensure compatibility with the latest versions of React. react-desktop is also designed specifically for React and integrates well into React applications. However, as it has a smaller community and less frequent updates, compatibility with other React libraries and tools might be a bit more limited.