Head-to-Head: Material-UI vs react-day-picker Analysis
@material-ui/core
v4.12.4(over 2 years ago)
@material-ui/core is a popular React component library that provides a set of customizable and accessible UI components for building modern web applications. It follows Google's Material Design guidelines, offering a wide range of components like buttons, cards, dialogs, and more, all styled with a consistent design language.
React Day Picker is a flexible and customizable date picker component for React applications. It provides a simple and intuitive way to select dates, ranges, and handle date-related interactions in your UI. With a focus on accessibility and keyboard navigation, React Day Picker offers a seamless user experience across different devices and browsers.
Alternatives:
react-datepicker-+
@mui/lab-+
react-dates-+
@hassanmojab/react-modern-calendar-datepicker-+
react-calendar-+
react-big-calendar-+
react-date-range-+
react-infinite-calendar-+
react-nice-dates-+
@datepicker-react/hooks-+
Tags: reactdate-pickercomponentUIaccessibility
Fight!
Popularity
@material-ui/core is a highly popular and widely used package in the React ecosystem. It has a large community following, extensive documentation, and is backed by Material-UI, a well-established UI library. react-day-picker, while not as popular as @material-ui/core, has a decent following and is specifically focused on providing a flexible and customizable date picker component.
UI Component Library vs Specific Component
@material-ui/core is a comprehensive UI component library that includes a wide range of components beyond just a date picker. It provides a consistent design system and a vast collection of customizable UI elements. On the other hand, react-day-picker is a specialized package specifically designed for building date pickers and related features. If you need a complete UI component library, @material-ui/core would be a better choice. However, if your primary requirement is a feature-rich and highly customizable date picker, react-day-picker might be more suitable.
Design and Styling
@material-ui/core follows the Material Design guidelines, providing a sleek and modern look out-of-the-box. It offers various pre-styled components that can be easily customized. react-day-picker, on the other hand, gives you the flexibility to customize the appearance and styling of the date picker according to your project's specific needs. It provides a set of CSS modules and allows for complete control over the styling.
Dependencies
@material-ui/core has a few direct dependencies and may require additional packages for certain advanced features. react-day-picker also has minimal dependencies, making it lightweight and easy to use in your project.
Documentation
@material-ui/core provides extensive and detailed documentation. It includes comprehensive guides, API references, usage examples, and a helpful community making it easy to get started and find answers to common questions. react-day-picker also has good documentation with clear examples and guides, although it is more focused on the specifics of the date picker component.
Developer Experience
@material-ui/core offers a great developer experience with well-documented APIs, TypeScript support, and a wide range of community-contributed extensions and themes. react-day-picker also provides a good developer experience with TypeScript support and a straightforward API. Both packages have active maintenance and regular updates.
