Head-to-Head: Headless UI React vs react-helmet-async Analysis

@headlessui/react

v2.0.4(28 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 4Monthly npm downloads

@headlessui/react is a library that provides fully accessible, customizable, and unstyled components for building user interfaces in React applications. It offers a set of headless UI components like buttons, menus, modals, and more, allowing developers to create accessible and interactive UI elements without the need for styling. The components are designed to be highly flexible and can be easily customized to fit the design requirements of any project.

Alternatives:
radix-ui+
reakit+
chakra-ui+
mantine+
react-bootstrap+
material-ui+
semantic-ui-react+
ant-design+
blueprintjs/core+
evergreen-ui+

Tags: reactui-componentsaccessibilityheadlesscustomizable

react-helmet-async

v2.0.5(about 2 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 3Monthly npm downloads

React Helmet Async is a library for managing document head tags in React applications asynchronously. It allows developers to dynamically update the title, meta tags, links, and other elements in the document head based on the current state of the application. React Helmet Async provides a simple and declarative API for managing SEO-related metadata, social media tags, and other document head content.

Alternatives:
react-helmet+
react-meta-tags+
next-seo+
react-document-meta+
react-head+
react-snap+
gatsby-plugin-react-helmet+
vue-meta+
next-head+
react-side-effect+

Tags: reactseodocument-headmetadataasynchronous

Fight!

Popularity

@headlessui/react and react-helmet-async are both popular npm packages within the React ecosystem. However, react-helmet-async has a larger user base and is more widely adopted.

Functionality

@headlessui/react is a set of completely unstyled, fully accessible UI components for React. It provides a solid foundation for building custom UI components. On the other hand, react-helmet-async is a library that allows you to manage and manipulate the document head of your React application, enabling you to dynamically update meta tags, titles, and other head elements.

Developer Experience

Both packages offer a good developer experience. @headlessui/react provides a collection of accessible and customizable UI components, which can save development time and effort. react-helmet-async simplifies the management of the document head, making it easy to handle SEO-related tasks. Both packages have well-documented APIs and active communities.

Integration

Both packages can be easily integrated into a React project. However, @headlessui/react requires some additional styling to be applied, as it provides unstyled components. react-helmet-async seamlessly integrates with React and can be used alongside other UI libraries or component frameworks.

Performance

In terms of performance, @headlessui/react is designed to be lightweight and optimized for performance. It provides a minimal set of unstyled components, which allows for better performance. react-helmet-async also has good performance characteristics, but its impact on performance depends on how it is used within the application.

Maintenance

Both packages are actively maintained by their respective communities. @headlessui/react is maintained by the Tailwind CSS team, ensuring regular updates and bug fixes. react-helmet-async is also well-maintained and has a history of regular updates.