Head-to-Head: Headless UI React vs Grommet Analysis

@headlessui/react

v1.7.18(3 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 2Monthly npm downloads

@headlessui/react is a library that provides fully accessible, customizable, and unstyled components for building user interfaces in React applications. It offers a set of headless UI components like buttons, menus, modals, and more, allowing developers to create accessible and interactive UI elements without the need for styling. The components are designed to be highly flexible and easy to integrate into existing projects, making it a popular choice for building inclusive web applications.

Alternatives:
radix-ui+
reakit+
chakra-ui+
mantine+
react-aria+
downshift+
react-hotkeys-hook+
react-table+
react-query+
react-spring+

Tags: reactui-componentsaccessibilityheadlesscustomizable

grommet

v2.36.1(25 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 4Monthly npm downloads

Grommet is a comprehensive React component library designed for building responsive and accessible web applications. It offers a wide range of customizable UI components, including buttons, forms, layouts, and data visualization elements. Grommet follows best practices for responsive design and accessibility, making it easy to create modern and user-friendly interfaces.

Alternatives:
antd+
material-ui+
chakra-ui+
blueprintjs+
semantic-ui-react+
rebass+
evergreen-ui+
react-bootstrap+
reactstrap+
primeReact+

Tags: reactcomponent-libraryuiresponsive-designaccessibility

Fight!

Popularity

Both @headlessui/react and Grommet are popular npm packages in the React ecosystem. However, Grommet has been around for longer and has gained a larger user base and community support compared to @headlessui/react.

Component Library

@headlessui/react is a lightweight, unstyled component library that provides accessible and headless building blocks for creating custom UI components. It focuses more on providing low-level utility components without any opinionated styling, allowing developers to have more control over the final UI design. On the other hand, Grommet is a feature-rich UI component library with pre-styled components and a robust theming system. It offers a wide range of ready-to-use components out of the box, making it ideal for rapid prototyping and building consistent user interfaces.

Customization and Theming

With @headlessui/react, developers have complete control over the styling and customization of their components. It provides a solid foundation for building UI components from scratch, which allows for greater flexibility and customization options. On the other hand, Grommet offers a powerful theming system and allows for easy customization through theme configuration. It provides pre-defined themes and customization options that enable developers to quickly adapt the visual style of their application without writing much CSS.

Developer Experience

Both packages provide good developer experiences, but they have different approaches. @headlessui/react focuses on simplicity and providing building blocks without any opinionated styling, which can be beneficial for developers who want more control over the styling and design. Grommet, on the other hand, provides a more opinionated and feature-rich development experience, offering a wide range of pre-styled components that can speed up development time and make it easier for developers to create consistent UIs.

Community and Support

Grommet has been established in the React community for a longer period of time and has a larger user base, which means it has a more active community and better support resources like tutorials, documentation, and community-driven plugins. However, @headlessui/react is gaining popularity and has an active community as well, although it may have fewer resources and community-driven projects compared to Grommet.