Head-to-Head: Fluent UI React vs React Desktop Analysis

@fluentui/react

v8.115.6(19 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 14Monthly npm downloads

@fluentui/react is a comprehensive UI component library for building web applications with a Fluent Design System. It provides a wide range of reusable and customizable components, including buttons, menus, modals, and more. The library follows modern design principles and offers a consistent and visually appealing user interface.

Alternatives:
@material-ui/core+
@chakra-ui/react+
@blueprintjs/core+
antd+
react-bootstrap+
semantic-ui-react+
rebass+
grommet+
evergreen-ui+
primereact+

Tags: javascriptreactui-componentsfluent-designuser-interface

react-desktop

v0.3.9(about 5 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.The package doesn't have any types definitionsNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

React Desktop is a UI component library for building desktop applications using React. It provides a set of customizable and responsive components that mimic the look and feel of native desktop applications. With React Desktop, you can easily create cross-platform desktop applications using familiar React syntax.

Alternatives:
react-spectrum+
blueprintjs+
evergreen-ui+
antd+
material-ui+
semantic-ui-react+
grommet+
chakra-ui+
rebass+
rsuite+

Tags: javascriptreactdesktopui-componentscross-platform

Fight!

Popularity

Both @fluentui/react and react-desktop have their own user bases, but @fluentui/react is generally more popular and widely adopted. @fluentui/react is developed by Microsoft and has a larger community, while react-desktop has a smaller user base and community support.

Component Library

@fluentui/react is a comprehensive UI component library designed for building web applications with a modern and fluent user interface. It offers a wide range of pre-built components and follows Microsoft's Fluent Design System. On the other hand, react-desktop specifically focuses on providing desktop-style UI components for React applications, aiming to mimic the look and feel of native desktop applications.

Customization and Theming

@fluentui/react provides extensive support for theming and customization. It offers a theming API that allows developers to easily customize the appearance of components to match their application's visual style. In contrast, react-desktop has limited theming capabilities and customization options.

Integration with React Ecosystem

Both packages seamlessly integrate with React and can be used in React projects. However, @fluentui/react has better integration with other popular libraries and frameworks in the React ecosystem, such as React Router and Redux. react-desktop, on the other hand, is more focused on providing desktop-specific components and may require additional integration efforts with other libraries or frameworks.

Documentation and Community Support

@fluentui/react has extensive and well-maintained documentation, including guides, API references, and examples. It also benefits from a large and active community, with support available on various platforms. react-desktop, while it has documentation, may not be as comprehensive or actively maintained, and its community support may be limited compared to @fluentui/react.

Maintenance and Future-Proofing

@fluentui/react is developed and maintained by Microsoft, ensuring its continued support and updates. It aligns with Microsoft's Fluent Design System and is actively improved and enhanced. react-desktop, on the other hand, has seen fewer updates and may have a less certain future in terms of long-term maintenance and compatibility with evolving React practices and versions.