Head-to-Head: Fluent UI React vs Geist UI Analysis

@fluentui/react

v8.118.8(7 days ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 14Monthly npm downloads

@fluentui/react is a set of React components that implement Microsoft's Fluent Design System. It provides a collection of customizable and accessible UI components for building web applications with a modern and consistent look and feel. The components are designed to be responsive and work seamlessly across different devices and screen sizes.

Alternatives:
@material-ui/core+
@chakra-ui/react+
@blueprintjs/core+
@adobe/react-spectrum+
rebass+
@geist-ui/react+
@primer/components+
@shopify/polaris+
antd+
semantic-ui-react+

Tags: reactui-componentsfluent-designresponsiveaccessibility

@geist-ui/react

v2.2.5(over 2 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 1Monthly npm downloads

@geist-ui/react is a modern and customizable React component library designed for building elegant and responsive user interfaces. It offers a wide range of UI components such as buttons, modals, layouts, and forms, all following a minimalist design approach. The library provides a seamless integration with React applications, allowing developers to quickly create visually appealing interfaces with ease.

Alternatives:
@chakra-ui/react+
@mui/material+
antd+
rebass+
grommet+
semantic-ui-react+
blueprintjs/core+
evergreen-ui+
rsuite+
react-bootstrap+

Tags: reactcomponent-libraryuser-interfaceresponsive-designcustomizable

Fight!

Popularity

Both @fluentui/react and @geist-ui/react are popular npm packages in the React ecosystem. @fluentui/react is backed by Microsoft and has a large community following. @geist-ui/react is a relatively newer package but has gained popularity for its modern and minimalistic design.

Design and Styling

@fluentui/react follows the Fluent UI design system, which provides a comprehensive set of components and styles for building enterprise-level applications. It offers a wide range of customizable components with a focus on accessibility and consistency. @geist-ui/react, on the other hand, follows the Geist UI design system, which offers a sleek and minimalistic design. It provides a smaller set of components but with a more modern and visually appealing look.

Component Library

@fluentui/react provides a vast collection of components, including complex ones like grids, menus, and data visualization components. It also offers a rich set of utility functions and hooks. @geist-ui/react, although relatively new, provides a growing collection of essential components like buttons, inputs, modals, and navigation components. It focuses on simplicity and ease of use.

Customization and Theming

Both packages offer customization and theming capabilities. @fluentui/react provides a robust theming system with support for customizing colors, typography, and other design tokens. It also offers a theming provider for easy integration. @geist-ui/react also supports theming and provides a ThemeProvider component for customizing the design system's colors and styles.

Developer Experience

@fluentui/react has extensive documentation, including guides, API references, and examples. It also has a mature ecosystem with tools like Fluent UI Storybook and Fluent UI Codesandbox for interactive development. @geist-ui/react has a well-documented API and provides examples and guides to get started. It also has a growing community and actively maintains its documentation.

Integration and Compatibility

@fluentui/react integrates well with other Microsoft products and services, making it a good choice for developers working in the Microsoft ecosystem. It also has official support for frameworks like React, Angular, and Vue. @geist-ui/react is a standalone package and can be easily integrated into any React project without any specific dependencies or requirements.