Head-to-Head: Chakra UI vs Material-UI Analysis

@chakra-ui/react

v2.8.2(7 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 53Monthly npm downloads

@chakra-ui/react is a popular React component library that provides a set of customizable and accessible UI components for building modern web applications. It follows a design system approach, offering a wide range of components like buttons, forms, modals, and more, with built-in theming and styling capabilities. The library is known for its flexibility, allowing developers to easily customize the appearance and behavior of components to match their design requirements.

Alternatives:
@mui/material+
antd+
rebass+
@blueprintjs/core+
@geist-ui/react+
@headlessui/react+
@reach/ui+
radix-ui+
grommet+
evergreen-ui+

Tags: reactcomponent-libraryUIthemingaccessibility

@material-ui/core

v4.12.4(about 2 years ago)

This package is deprecated: Material UI v4 doesn't receive active development since September 2021. See the guide https://mui.com/material-ui/migration/migration-v4/ to upgrade to v5.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 12Monthly npm downloads

@material-ui/core is a popular React component library that provides a set of customizable and accessible UI components for building modern web applications. It follows Google's Material Design guidelines, offering a wide range of components like buttons, cards, dialogs, and more, all styled with a consistent design language.

Alternatives:
@mui/material+
antd+
chakra-ui+
blueprintjs/core+
react-bootstrap+
semantic-ui-react+
rebass+
grommet+
evergreen-ui+
primevue+

Tags: reactui-componentsmaterial-designaccessiblecustomizable

Fight!

Popularity

Both @chakra-ui/react and @material-ui/core are popular UI component libraries in the React ecosystem. @material-ui/core has been around longer and is widely used in many projects. However, @chakra-ui/react has gained significant popularity due to its modern design and developer-friendly API.

Component Set

@material-ui/core provides a comprehensive set of UI components, covering a wide range of use cases. It includes components like buttons, forms, modals, navigation, and more. @chakra-ui/react also offers a rich set of components, and it emphasizes accessibility and customization with its design system approach.

Design and Styling

Both libraries have different design approaches. @material-ui/core follows the Material Design principles and provides pre-built components with a consistent Material UI look and feel. @chakra-ui/react, on the other hand, has its own design system and offers more modern and customizable components out of the box.

Developer Experience

@material-ui/core has been a go-to choice for many developers due to its extensive documentation, large community, and well-established best practices. It has a mature ecosystem with various resources and ready-to-use themes. @chakra-ui/react also provides good documentation, but it offers a more intuitive API and has a more modern and beginner-friendly developer experience.

Theming and Customization

Both libraries support theming and customization. @material-ui/core has a robust theming API that allows easy customization of colors, typography, and other aspects of the design. @chakra-ui/react takes theming a step further and provides a comprehensive theme object along with design tokens that allow for greater control and consistency in UI customization.

Performance

In terms of performance, both libraries are well-optimized. However, @chakra-ui/react's design system approach and use of styled-components result in a smaller bundle size compared to @material-ui/core. Additionally, @chakra-ui/react adopts a more modern rendering approach, which can lead to improved performance in certain scenarios.