Head-to-Head: 11ty vs React Static Analysis

@11ty/eleventy

v2.0.1(about 1 year ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 38Monthly npm downloads

Eleventy, also known as @11ty/eleventy, is a static site generator built with JavaScript that allows developers to create fast and flexible websites. It focuses on simplicity and ease of use, providing a minimal setup and configuration process. Eleventy supports various template languages like Markdown, HTML, and JavaScript, giving developers the flexibility to choose the best approach for their projects. It also offers a rich plugin ecosystem for extending its functionality and integrating with other tools.

Alternatives:
hugo+
gatsby+
next+
nuxt+
hexo+
jekyll+
vuepress+
gridsome+
docusaurus+
sapper+

Tags: javascriptstatic-site-generatorflexibleplugin-ecosystemmodern

react-static

v7.6.2(over 2 years ago)

This package was last published over a year ago. It may not be actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 71Monthly npm downloads

React-Static is a modern static site generator for React, enabling developers to build fast and SEO-friendly websites with React components. It offers server-side rendering, code splitting, and preloading capabilities to optimize performance and user experience. React-Static simplifies the process of creating static websites by providing a flexible and intuitive API for managing routes, data fetching, and content rendering.

Alternatives:
next.js+
gatsby+
nuxt.js+
blitz+
redwoodjs+
sapper+
frontity+
vitepress+
elderjs+
hugo+

Tags: reactstatic-site-generatorserver-side-renderingperformanceSEO

Fight!

Static Site Generation

Both @11ty/eleventy and react-static are powerful static site generators. @11ty/eleventy is known for its simplicity and flexibility, allowing developers to create static websites with various templating languages like Nunjucks, Handlebars, and more. React-static, as the name suggests, is specifically built for React-based static site generation. It offers a highly optimized build process and supports React components out of the box.

Developer Experience

Both packages provide a good developer experience, but there are differences in terms of familiarity and learning curve. @11ty/eleventy can be a good choice for developers with a background in templating languages or who prefer a simpler configuration setup. React-static is targeted towards developers familiar with React and its ecosystem, providing a more modern and JavaScript-centric development experience.

Community and Ecosystem

React-static benefits from the popularity of React, which has a large and active community. This means that there are abundant resources, tutorials, and plugins available for React-static. On the other hand, @11ty/eleventy has a smaller but growing community and a focused ecosystem around static site generation. It may require more effort to find specific resources compared to React-static.

Performance

Both packages have good performance characteristics. @11ty/eleventy generates highly optimized static websites without the need for a client-side runtime, resulting in fast page load times. React-static utilizes React's server-side rendering (SSR) capabilities, allowing for dynamic content generation during the build process and fast initial page loads. However, for more interactive and dynamic applications, React-static's client-side interactivity may cause a slightly slower time-to-interactive compared to @11ty/eleventy's pre-rendered static content.

Flexibility and Extensibility

@11ty/eleventy offers a lot of flexibility in terms of templating languages, data sources, and configuration options. It allows developers to bring their own tools and integrate with other build processes. React-static, on the other hand, is more opinionated and focused on React. It provides a plugin system to extend its functionality, but customization options outside the React ecosystem might be limited.

Learning Curve

@11ty/eleventy has a relatively low learning curve, especially for developers with experience in templating languages. It has straightforward documentation and a simple configuration setup. React-static, on the other hand, requires familiarity with React and its ecosystem, including concepts like JSX, components, and React Router. This learning curve might be steeper for developers who are new to React.

Scalability and Complexity

Both @11ty/eleventy and React-static can handle small to medium-sized projects effectively. @11ty/eleventy's simplicity and flexibility make it suitable for projects of various sizes. React-static leverages React's robust ecosystem, making it a good choice for projects that require extensive React-specific features and scalability. However, as projects grow in complexity and size, React-static's dependency on React might introduce some additional complexities compared to the simplicity of @11ty/eleventy.