Head-to-Head: 11ty vs Gatsby Analysis

@11ty/eleventy

v2.0.1(11 months ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 38Monthly npm downloads

@11ty/eleventy is a static site generator built with JavaScript. It allows you to create fast and flexible websites using simple templates and data files. Eleventy supports various templating languages such as Markdown, Nunjucks, Handlebars, and more, giving you the flexibility to choose the one that suits your needs.

Alternatives:
hexo+
gatsby+
hugo-cli+
vuepress+
gridsome+
nuxt+
next+
jekyll+
pelican+
metalsmith+

Tags: javascriptstatic-site-generatortemplatingmarkdownnunjucks

gatsby

v5.13.3(about 1 month ago)

This package is actively maintained.Types definitions are bundled with the npm packageNumber of direct dependencies: 168Monthly npm downloads

Gatsby is a modern and powerful static site generator built with React. It allows developers to build fast and optimized websites using the latest web technologies. Gatsby leverages the concept of pre-rendering, where the HTML, CSS, and JavaScript are generated at build time, resulting in lightning-fast page loads and improved SEO.

Alternatives:
next+
nuxt+
gridsome+
frontity+
sapper+
blitz+
redwoodjs+
remix+
vuepress+
astro+

Tags: javascriptstatic-site-generatorreactpre-renderingperformance

Fight!

Popularity

Gatsby is more popular than Eleventy in terms of community adoption and usage. Gatsby has gained significant popularity due to its powerful features, extensive plugin ecosystem, and strong support for building static websites and progressive web applications.

Architecture

Eleventy is a simpler and more lightweight static site generator compared to Gatsby. It focuses on simplicity, speed, and easy customization. On the other hand, Gatsby is a more comprehensive framework that uses React and GraphQL to build static websites with a rich developer experience.

Learning Curve

Eleventy has a smaller learning curve as it requires a basic understanding of templating languages like HTML, JavaScript, and Markdown. Gatsby, on the other hand, has a steeper learning curve due to its usage of React, GraphQL, and its own ecosystem of plugins and configurations.

Flexibility

Eleventy provides more flexibility in terms of choosing your own stack, templating language, and asset pipeline. It supports a wide range of templating languages and allows you to use your preferred build tools. Gatsby, with its React and GraphQL approach, provides a more opinionated setup and is well-suited for larger, data-intensive websites.

Performance

Eleventy is known for its exceptional performance due to its simple architecture and minimal build process. It generates static HTML files that are fast to load. Gatsby, although powerful, can have a longer build time due to its more complex webpack-based build process and dynamic rendering of pages.

Extensibility

Both Eleventy and Gatsby have extension ecosystems where you can find plugins to extend their functionality. Gatsby has a larger plugin ecosystem with more options and support due to its popularity, while Eleventy's ecosystem is smaller but growing steadily.